To defer or to async JavaScript tags. That's the question.

29 June 2018   0 comments   Web development, Javascript, Web Performance

tl;dr; async scores slightly better that defer (on script tags) in this experiment using Webpagetest.

Much has been written about the difference between <script defer src="..."> and <script async src="..."> but nothing beats seeing it visually in Webpagetest.

Here are some good articles/resources:

So I took a page off my own blog. Butchered it and cleaned up the 6 <script> tags. It uses HTTP/2 and some jQuery and some other vanilla JavaScript stuff. See the page here: neither.html
Then I copied that HTML file and replaced all <script src="..."> with <script defer src="...">: defer.html. And lastly, the same with: async.html.

First let's compare all three against each other:

Neither vs defer vs async
Neither vs defer vs async on Webpagetest.

Clearly, making the JavaScript non-blocking is critical for web performance. That's 1.7 seconds instead of 2.8 seconds.

Second, let's compare just defer vs. async on a 4G connection:

defer vs. async on 4G
defer vs. async on 4G Also, if you like here's defer vs. async on a desktop browser instead.


  1. Don't allow your JavaScript to block rendering unless it's OK to have your users staring at a white screen till everything has landed.

  2. There's not much difference between defer and async. async has a slight advantage as per these experiments. I'm only capable of guessing, but I suspect it's because it can "spread out" the work better and get some work done in parallel whilst defer has things that tell it to wait. In particular, since with defer the order of the <script> tags is respected. Suppose that the file some.jquery.plugin.js downloads before jquery.min.js, then that file has to be blocked and execution delayed whilst waiting for jquery.min.js to download, parse and execute. With async it's more of a wild west of executing whenever you can.

  3. The async.html is busted because of the unpredictable order of execution and these .js files depend on the order. Another reason to use defer if your scripts have that order-dependency problem.

  4. Consider using a mix of async and defer. async has the advantage that some parsing/execution can be done by the main thread whilst waiting for other blocking resources like images.


Your email will never ever be published

Related posts

A good Django view function cache decorator for http.JsonResponse 20 June 2018
Related by Keyword:
To CDN assets or just HTTP/2 17 May 2018
The impressive first-meaningful-paint improvement of using minimalcss 24 April 2018
More CSS load performance experiments (of a React app) 25 March 2017
Web Performance Optimization of a Single-Page-App and web fonts 16 March 2017
CSS Bloat Comparison 03 June 2016
Related by Text:
jQuery and Highslide JS 08 January 2008
I'm back! has been renewed 05 June 2005
Anti-McCain propaganda videos 12 August 2008
I'm Prolog 01 May 2007
Ever wondered how much $87 Billion is? 04 November 2003