YSlow grade A (96) but not with doubts If you're a web developer and care about having snappy web sites you'll know about YSlow for Firebug. I managed to get a grade A (96) but I'm suspecting that there's a bug in the YSlow analysis.

Setting an Expires header is inferior to using Cache-Control which my site was already using fine with headers like:

Cache-Control: public,max-age=3600

according to the latest documentation but YSlow kept going on about setting Expires headers. I prefer Cache-Control since you don't have to do any date formatting which eats a few excess CPU cycles. If anybody knows why it's a good idea to use both Cache-Control and Expires let me know.

A more worrying possible bug in YSlow is that it's date comparison on the Expires header is wrong. I use the RFC1123 format for the Expires header which uses GMT which means today that the output looks like it's one hour behind since we're (here) in BST (British summer time). Here are the different outputs:

`date` on command line           Fri Aug  6 17:26:36 BST 2007
looking at my wrist watch        17:26
RFC 1123                         Fri, 06 Aug 2007 16:26:36 GMT
(RFC 822                         Fri, 06 Aug 2007 17:26:36 +0100)

If I add 5 min to the RFC 1123 YSlow claims the date is not in the future which is incorrect. To get my A grade I set the Expires future parameter to be 1 hour and 5 min ahead to not confuse YSlow's date comparison. But if YSlow gets it wrong perhaps HTTP accelerators (eg. Squid) and web browsers might get it wrong too.

This site isn't launched yet but one of the things I'm quite proud of is that I'm managed to whitespace-strip, merge and gzip the javascript files and the css files and all of this happens once per server reload meaning there's nothing dynamic in these files but when I make a change all I have to do is save the file and the system automatically recompiles a new merged, stripped and gzipped version absolutely seamlessly.

This is the first time I've put the Javascript at the bottom of the page which I'm not used to and slightly unsure what side effects that might have to the rendering. We'll see.


Your email will never ever be published.

Related posts